Hi Ralph,
Congratulations! With your current USATT rating at 1177, that's
impressive! It's true, working on serves makes it possible to beat
players at a whole new level.
In fact, I thought I'd share what I taught you, so I've written it
down here, and now I've put it on my website. Here it is.
Technically, having a perfect serve means that you have perfect
consistency with serve shots covering the entire range of extreme
properties. The extreme properties described here begin from obvious
ones of maximum and minimum distance, angles that are sharpest or most
effective, and different kinds of simple spins; then we move on to the
bread-and-butter of unreturnable serves -- the invisible,
unpredictable high-toss serve mixing corkscrew with topspin or chop;
and finally we end with strategic thinking: probe, watch, and
think, to find and then pound on their weaknesses.
Corkscrew spin is just what you think, the ball rotates around its own
line of travel. Corkscrew means the axis of the rotation is (more)
parallel to the line of travel, instead of perpendicular. Topspin,
sidespin, underspin, all have the axis of rotation of the ball
perpendicular to the line of flight. With topspin and underspin, that
axis is parallel to the ground. With sidespin, the axis is vertical.
But with corkscrew, the axis is in the line of travel.
The way to produce corkscrew is to do a medium or high
toss, so the ball has significant downward momentum at contact,
then contact the ball on its side with a forward and lifting motion.
The forward motion makes it travel forward; the lifting
combined with the ball's downward momentum gives it a rotating
spin. Different combinations of these vectors can
give the ball more or less corkscrew, more or less forward velocity;
it is possible to have only a little corkscrew, or a lot,
and to do many-bounce dink serves as well as medium-fast serves.
Concentrate on the bounciness of the ball's contact with the tackiness
of the rubber, and feel it tug at your paddle as the tackiness bites
into the side of it. Enjoy the miracle of spin, and play with it
until you feel you know intuitively how to produce it.
When working on heavy spin, don't worry about where the ball goes,
just think about the power and tackiness and spin and the whippy,
tugging, slicing action through that contact point. Only after you get
good spin should you think about pointing it in the right
direction. Then you can use that slicing motion to really put the
juice on it.
Then once you get a good set of hyper-spin-generating stroke motions,
you won't need any more advice from me to figure out for yourself how
to control shots that hit the extreme distances and angles. It's just
a matter of practice. Fortunately you can practice all you want, even
with no practice partner: I've gotten a lot from hanging a
blanket around a kitchen table, to catch the balls as I spin them.
It can be an adjustment to get the feeling of a hyper-slicing,
spin-tugging stroke in a new posture.
For forehand serves, use a wide stance perpendicular to the table, and
weight-shift your body sideways over your feet in the direction of
your opponent, shifting a good 8-15 inches during the forward stroke.
This will improve your power and consistency.
Pingpong is a hand-eye coordination sport. Therefore getting your
eyes close to the ball will improve your quality of play. This means
bend your knees, bend your hips, because if you're 6'2" like me, you
can't get your eyes close to the ball if you're standing straight up.
Stand like an athlete, playing a sport: bend your knees!
When serving, bend your knees and hips enough to bring your eyes close
to the level of the table. You'll feel like this is silly, it's only
pingpong, how can I do that, but it's a sport, so bend down and get
your head at the level of the ball.
After you get that, do it with side contact to produce a dink
corkscrew serve, and after that with side-back-lifting contact to
produce a topspin-corkscrew dink serve.
The serve-and-kill game is extremely effective: if you have a super
service game, then even if you can't get them to miss every shot, you
can often get them to pop up a high percentage of those they do
return. So if you have a really great serve, you need to also develop
great consistency in killing easy pop-up returns, otherwise all your
service skills will go to waste producing squandered opportunities.
The optimally-hidden serve is now the serve in which the paddle and
paddle motion are invisible or disguised during as much as
possible of the stroke.
I consider Ma Lin to be the master of the visible/invisible serve. He
contacts the ball with the paddle horizontal, and either it cuts
heavily producing strong underspin, or it touches flatly producing no
spin. The movement of the hand and paddle in the direction of the
line of sight of the opponent make the movement essentially invisible.
Therefore it is possible to put either heavy underspin or no spin on
the ball without the opponent being able to tell what happened.
I have developed a visible/invisible serve similar to Ma Lin's,
with some changes:
On the down side, the point of contact must be farther away from the
table in order both to sweep under the table in this forward stroke
and to contact the ball high enough that it can bounce gently over the
net in the usual two-bounce dink serve. This gives the opponent a
little bit more time to see what's coming and to respond.
Another problem of this serve is that it requires a lot of practice to
get it right: heavy underspin while stroking from high to low is a
harder than if stroking entirely horizontally. If you want, use the
Ma Lin technique of horizontal stroke above the table level, but the
opponent will be able to see your follow through. Eventually, though,
it is possible to do a strong spin / no spin alternation which is very
difficult to see. The Perfect Serve
I'm thinking about high-level, world-class skills in
the table tennis service game. I don't know very many players in the
US that have fully optimized on these characteristics, including
plenty of US 2400 level players. But if you watch Liu Guoliang on a
tape in slow-motion, you'll see what can be done. He has the best
serve in the world, as far as I'm concerned. His bread and butter are
serves that are all completely hidden through-the-armpit serves,
(illegal since the 2002 rule change, which has led to his
retirement as a player) with
lots of variation in speed and spin-direction, and lots of mixed-spin
serves, primarily corkscrew mixed in with topspin and chop. Even his
follow-through remains hidden on the service because he stays fully
counter-rotated through the follow-through -- and that doesn't affect
his 3rd-ball return, because he has a two-footed hop-rotation, where
he lands both feet in his ready position. Over and over the same
general structure, but what comes out, his opponents can't guess, can
barely detect the primary corkscrew spin direction in time, and
definitely can't see the subordinate topspin and chop spins mixed into
the corkscrew, which are what mostly ends up popping the ball up or
dropping it into the net.
Distance
Angle
Spin
Unpredictability
Invisibility
So in your repertoire you need serves that can be long or short; to
the opponent's far left, body or far right; with topspin, chop or
neither and either pure or combined with left or right sidespin and
especially also combined with corkscrew; all done without the opponent
being able to predict it (because you mix them up well); or (most
especially) to see what the spin is except by watching the ball
itself. Your job is to be as aggressive and unpredictable as you can
while remaining consistent, and focussing on their weaknesses, so that
they either pop up your service for a kill, or miss the table entirely.
How to Develop the Perfect Serve
Develop Heavy Spin
Practice alone in your kitchen or on a table someplace to FIND YOUR
OWN HYPER-SPIN STROKES, using a whippy, slicing motion until it seems
really intuitive and natural to you, how to get a real tug feeling
where the paddle slices and the ball spins. That tug feeling is what
spin is all about.
Stance
You can train away from the table without worrying much about your posture, but
when you serve at the table, posture and stance are important. Think about your grip.
Super-short serves
Practice a CHOP DINK serve, where you really get 3 bounces on the
other side of the net. I'm serious! You should be able to make it
bounce 5 times if you really want to, and without a lot of height on
the bounce. This requires a medium-high toss and a quite
horizontal blade at contact point. Practice this a lot till you have
it down, several minutes straight in each of many sessions! And use
it in matches after a few long serves and your opponent will collapse
on their face. It is very funny when they're standing back expecting a
power blast and your dink chop serve leaves their paddle clattering on
the table.
Pound those popups
Whenever you receive a high-bounce return, more than twice the height
of the net, kill it. You need to develop the ability to put away
popup returns and to become very confident about it. Even if you miss
badly for a while, make it a rule to always kill them, every time, and
then gradually you'll get so you start putting them away. Don't sweat
the errors, your job is to learn something and get better, and you
have to try it if you want to learn it. So just go for it and whallop
them. This section teaches the now-illegal hidden serve
Read it for the information in it, but learn the semi-hidden
serve described in the next section.
Develop the Hidden Serve
At a certain level, maybe 1700 or so, players get so they can read
visible spins from the sight of the ball contact and can respond
correctly no matter how heavy it is; you can really only beat
1300-1500 players with plain heavy spin, even if it is unpredictable,
because if they can see it, they can respond to it. So if you want to
really advance farther, you need to develop your ability to make
INVISIBLE SERVES. Even the top American players have not really
optimized this, unlike the top international players. There's a
huge amount of potential advantage that you can develop by building up
your skills at the hidden serve.
Develop the Visible/Invisible Serve
The new service rules have made important changes, including
both relaxing as well as tightening the rules.
These changes imply certain modifications in the optimal service
repertoire.
This means that under-the-armpit serves are illegal.
In this service, because the opponent cannot see the hand and paddle
movement before or after the point of contact, he or she is much less
able to read the spin. Because the essential spin/no-spin movement is
in the line of sight between the opponent and the ball, it is even
harder to read.