D: At each time there is an element at V (a vowel).
E: At each time there is an element at T (a tone).
Proof of WFC #1: Choose an arbitrary vowel, call it v. By universality and immediacy, v occurs at some time, tv. But E states that there exists a tone at every time so there must a tone at tv. Therefore there is a tone at the same time as that vowel. Since the vowel was chosen arbitrarily, this is true for every vowel.
Proof of WFC #2: A symmetrical argument applies, with ``tone'' and ``vowel'' interchanged, and ``D'' replacing ``E''.
Proof of WFC #3: Association lines in non-linear phonology correspond to simultaneous occurrence in an LT system. The corresponding claim made by clause 3 is that if an element v1 precedes another element v2, then elements cotemporal with v1 and v2, say t1 and t2, may not occur in the opposite order as their cotemporal elements. Considerthe following propositions, i-iv, where < encodes ``precedes'' and @ encodes association lines or simultaneity.
i: v1@t1.
ii: v2@t2.
iii: v1 < v2.
iv: t2 < t1.
Clause 3 of the Well-Formedness Condition essentially states that given i-iii, iv is ruled out. However, this follows trivially from fundamental assumptions about Linguistic time-and-place. By universality and immediacy, v1 occurs at some time; let's call it 1. By proposition i, t1 is also at time 1. Similarly, v2 and t2 occur at some time, which we may call 2. Since v1 precedes v2, the time, 1, at which v1 occurs, precedes the time, 2, at which v2 occurs. But since t1 follows t2, the time at which t1 occurs, 1, follows the time at which t2 occurs, 2. But by linearity, one time may not both precede and follow another. Therefore 1 cannot both precede and follow 2, and one of our assumptions must be incorrect. To maintain propositions i-iii, we must abandon iv. QED.
The Well-Formedness Condition is at the very heart of non-linear phonology. The derivation of Clauses 1, 2, and 3 of the WFC from independent principles may therefore be considered an important achievement of an explicitly spatio-temporal perspective on linguistic representations.A.6